READER'S VIEW: Aussie Army actions not deserving of respect

LET me thank Harry Johns (TMB 16/7) for being amazed that our Peace Convergence was able to generate such far-reaching criticism of the US alliance and the ramping up of militarism nationally and regionally. We are, after all, few in number and cash poor. The combination of truth, commitment and creativity is what gives wings to our words.

I can also agree with Harry that our soldiers need our support and respect. But I say that respect ought not be given without question.

Integrating our armed services into US command and mindlessly following the US military into futile foreign wars in which our national security never was or is at stake, are not accomplishments deserving respect.

The ADF adventure in Afghanistan, for example, is the longest (12 years), most costly ($9.3billion) and most futile war ever by our military. Our SAS Regiment there was engaged in murder, abduction and torture. It was costing us taxpayers $1million per soldier per year to keep the troops safe on the ground plus a $50million bribe (http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/good-weekend/all-that-remains-our-questionable-legacy-in-afghanistan-20150703-ghpley) to the Uruzgan police chief to guarantee roads free of IEDs.

These are not glory moments for our military. No poignant Last Post moments will ever erase the suffering of the families of the dead, maimed and mentally afflicted delivered by that extended exercise in futility.

No benefits will compensate the cost to our Commonwealth. Nor will respect ever be accorded the leadership of the ADF which chose silence, compliance and careers over truth and the national interest in this regard.

And it goes on: $400 million per year for troops in Iraq. For what?

From Byfield residents I have heard that when reservists came from Townsville to help clean up after Cyclone Marcia, they were warmly and proudly embraced by the community. They worked hard and loved the work and people loved them for it.

This is the defence force for which I yearn. Of the people and for the people. And smart enough to avoid following a dangerous ally into catastrophe.

Graeme Dunstan

Rockhampton